Welcome to Paper Street Coffee - Cresskill, a charming coffee shop nestled at 22 B Union Ave, Cresskill, NJ. Known for its warm and inviting atmosphere, this delightful café is quickly becoming a favored spot among locals seeking a quality coffee experience.
At Paper Street Coffee, the menu is a treasure trove for coffee enthusiasts. From the smooth House Coffee to the decadent Mocha and the elegantly crafted Cappuccino, each drink speaks to the baristas’ commitment to quality. For those in search of something unique, the Espresso Bombon offers a rich and indulgent experience with its harmonious blend of espresso and condensed milk, while the maple latte made with almond milk has become a hit for those seeking a low-sugar, dairy-free option.
Utility meets beauty here; the Merch & Items - Coffee Bags available for purchase, such as Stella, Marla, and The Narrator, allow coffee lovers to take a piece of the café home, ensuring that the Paper Street experience continues long after your visit.
But it's not just the coffee that's making waves. Customers rave about the delightful pastries and snacks that perfectly complement their drinks. From the whimsical cinnamon roll pastry to the refreshing avocado toast, there’s something for everyone. As noted by one satisfied visitor, it’s a cozy spot perfect for unwinding or enjoying engaging conversations with friends.
What sets Paper Street Coffee apart is the genuine warmth of its staff. Patrons have consistently shared their appreciation for the attentive service, exemplified by stories of friendly baristas who go above and beyond to enhance the overall experience. This caring approach, paired with awesome music and community-focused decor, fosters a welcoming vibe that makes you want to linger longer.
As you step into this quaint café, whether for a mid-day pick-me-up or a leisurely weekend brunch, you can expect a celebration of coffee, community, and conviviality. It’s more than just a place to grab a cup; it’s a destination where quality meets comfort, making Paper Street Coffee - Cresskill a must-visit for coffee aficionados and casual drinkers alike. Don't miss out on this gem in Cresskill – you just might find your new favorite café.
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
Am Markt 7, 23966 Wismar, Germany
Domingo Faustino Sarmiento 190, B2700 Pergamino, Provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina
Willmersreuth 10, 95336 Mainleus, Germany
Quai Arthur Rimbaud, 66750 Saint-Cyprien, France
23B En Fournirue, 57000 Metz, France
Merytel Rodriguez
12/10/2025
Went to Paper Street Coffee on a gloomy Monday afternoon for a mid-day pick me up and had a great time! I asked the barista for his recommendation as I’m low sugar and dairy free. He recommended the maple latte made with almond milk and it was delicious and beautiful! The milk wasn’t watery which can happen with non dairy milks like almond, and it had the right amount of sweetness to it, just enough to cut the bitterness espresso can sometimes have. The music selection was awesome too!
Tamir Gershovitz
08/10/2025
I had such a great experience at Paper Street Coffee. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with a cozy vibe that makes it a perfect spot to relax or catch up with friends. The coffee is excellent rich, smooth, and clearly made with care. They also have a nice selection of pastries and snacks that pair perfectly with the drinks. The staff is friendly and attentive, which really adds to the overall experience. Definitely one of the best coffee spots in the area!
Laren E
30/09/2025
I absolutely plan to return to this little cafe! The employee was friendly. I enjoyed a delicious matcha latte, a lovely little cinnamon roll pastry, and avocado toast. Just be aware that this cafe is primarily for drinks, pastries, and vibes. If you're looking for a place with a large food selection or a big hearty meal, you won't find it here. If you want delicious cafe beverages and a pastry snack (or avocado toast) this is the place for you! They even have a cute kids beverage menu. Definitely recommend!
Denise
13/09/2025
From the moment I walked into the café I had a wonderful experience! My mother and I were greeted by this wonderful Colombian barista (unfortunately I didn’t catch his name-I was there Sunday afternoon). He treated us so well! Definitely went above and beyond during our experience at the café. Excellent job to you! We ordered a maple latte, hot chocolate, pandebono & Nutella bread pudding. Honestly everything was so yummy! I loveddddd the hot chocolate and bread pudding the MOST!! Definitely worth dining in often! Def check this place out if you are wondering about it :) Also, the price was awesome! … one of my fav local cafés now!
Carson Gibbs
02/09/2025
Just tried the espresso bombon at what I think may be the newest coffee shop in town, and it was fantastic! The rich espresso paired perfectly with the condensed milk, creating a smooth and indulgent flavor. Plus I got a little fancy chocolate to pair with it. I also liked the pictures on the wall. From what I can tell they're pictures of stuff that has happened in the area which is great. I love a shop that celebrates its community. Definitely going to order some of their roasted coffee for myself once I run out of my current bag.
Nicole Banales
20/08/2025
Really nice and amicable barista who helped us with the menu and suggesting items. We both got the milpresso which is a Milo milk latte (I got mine with oat milk though). My boyfriend got the Nutella bread pudding which was very decadent and good. It’s a big portion so he didn’t finish. I got the guava empanada but the bread was a little too dense for my liking. It was also pretty big. So make sure you get them to share.
Rachel Zager
29/07/2025
The best service I’ve received at a coffee shop! Even though only one barista was working register and making drinks, he was still kind, attentive, and answered my questions. I was able to customize my latte and it tasted delicious! If I lived in the area, I’d definitely be a regular here.
Avi Golan
20/07/2025
Paper Street Coffee is hands down one of the best coffee spots around! The quality of the coffee is outstanding — you can really taste the difference in their beans. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for relaxing or catching up with friends. The staff is always friendly, helpful, and make you feel welcome right away. On top of that, their pastries and avocado toast are fresh and delicious. Definitely my go-to spot whenever I’m in the area!